Summary

The Arab political scientist cited by Will Kymlicka in Stateless Citizenship (2013) for the argument that the Israeli national project should be considered and included as a European settler-colonial state — on which inclusion the Palestinians inside and outside Israel’s imagined borders would meet the traditional definition of an indigenous people (Stateless Citizenship (2013), PDF p.60).

Details

  • The citation given is Amal Jamal, “On the Morality of Arab Collective Rights in Israel,” Adalah’s Newsletter 12 (April 2005) (PDF p.60, footnote 10).

  • In Stateless Citizenship (2013) Chapter 5, Jamal’s account is given at length: Israel as a “nationalizing state” renders indigenous minorities’ citizenship a Hollow Citizenship “devoid of substantive cultural, economic and political meaning” (Jamal 2007, 473, as quoted), because “mere Palestinian-Arab existence” challenges the state’s vision; the frameworks of exclusion “feed off and promote one another” (Jamal 2007, 489, as quoted) (PDF p.191-192). Jamal’s Arab Minority Nationalism in Israel: The Politics of Indigeneity (2011) is also noted among the three major 2011 publications on Palestinian citizens (PDF p.184, footnote 20).

Stateless Citizenship (2013), Will Kymlicka, Indigeneity, Settler Colonialism