Summary

The second wave of Zionist immigration to Palestine, whose members’ first impressions of the country’s indigenous people are the central evidence of Shtetl Colonialism: First and Last Impressions of Indigeneity by Colonised Colonisers: the core group, mainly from Russia and from the Shtetl townships of the Pale of Settlement, from which the past Zionist and present Israeli Jewish leadership sprang (Shtetl Colonialism: First and Last Impressions of Indigeneity by Colonised Colonisers, PDF p.5, p.9-10 / printed p.43, p.47-48).

Details

  • Size as given in the article, without a note: the core group numbered between 20,000 and 40,000 people, constituting only 4% of those who left Russia at the time; 90% of them left mainly to the US, so the group that remained was only a few thousand strong (PDF p.9-10).
  • Its members were compulsory diarists and letter writers, published in The Book of the Second Aliya (1947), and their first anti-Arab entries were written while they were still hosted by Palestinians on the way to the old colonies or in the towns (PDF p.10).
  • In Palestine they rebuilt gated communities, expelled the Palestinian workforce from the old Jewish colonies — Kibbush Ha-Avoda, the Conquest of the Labour Market — and laid the foundations for the future state; self-exclusion produced the first pure settlements and then paramilitary guarding of the enclaves (PDF p.9-10). See Conquest of Labour.
  • The self-depiction of Zionism as colonialism ended after the Second Aliya, in the article’s account: the early settlers were described by the Second Aliya as colonists, and anyone who preferred Arab workers was in turn a despicable colonist to them (PDF p.9, note 14).
  • The strongest and most common message of its voices, as Pappé summarises them, is the need to exclude the Palestinians in order to turn Palestine into a safe haven for Jews (PDF p.15 / printed p.53).

Shtetl Colonialism: First and Last Impressions of Indigeneity by Colonised Colonisers, The Book of the Second Aliya, Shtetl, Conquest of Labour, David Ben-Gurion